The Government ATTACKS Dishonest CAR Dealers

That bargain price on a new car may be nothing more than bait. You see the ad, compare prices, and head to the dealership. Then come the mandatory packages, dealer fees, and discounts you may not qualify for. Suddenly, the advertised price is nowhere near the amount you are expected to pay.

Now, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) is targeting dealerships accused of deceptive pricing practices. The allegations highlight why car dealership deceptive pricing remains a major concern for consumers.

FTC Alleges Car Buyers Paid Thousands More

On October 8, 2026, the FTC announced a proposed settlement with Greenway Auto Group. According to the agency, customers paid an average of more than $3,350 above the advertised price in over 92% of the transactions it reviewed.

The complaint cites administrative fees, dealer fees, delivery charges, processing fees, and additional packages. It also alleges that some advertised discounts were unavailable to certain buyers. These claims remain allegations and are not a final court finding.

The FTC further alleges that Greenway sent mailers suggesting consumers had won cash prizes they could collect at a dealership, without accurately representing those prizes. The agency says it warned the company about its pricing practices in March 2026.

For car buyers, the problem is straightforward. An attractive advertised price gets them through the door, but the actual cost may not become clear until they have invested time, traveled to the dealership, and started negotiating.

Greenway Is Not the Only Dealership Facing Scrutiny

The FTC and Maryland authorities have also pursued Lindsay Automotive Group over alleged deceptive pricing and unwanted add-ons.

The FTC alleged that 88% of customers in a sample of transactions paid more than the advertised price. The complaints also described alleged pressure involving dealer financing and products customers were told they had to purchase.

These cases do not prove that every dealership uses deceptive pricing. However, they raise an important question: How can consumers compare vehicle prices fairly when the advertised amount may not reflect what they will actually pay?

FTC Targets Hidden Fees and Misleading Car Prices

The federal Combating Auto Retail Scams (CARS) Rule was vacated by a federal appeals court in January 2025 on procedural grounds and later withdrawn. However, the rule’s withdrawal did not make deceptive advertising legal.

In March 2026, the FTC warned 97 dealership groups about potentially deceptive pricing practices. The concerns included mandatory fees excluded from advertised prices, conditional rebates, required add-ons, and vehicles that might not be available at the advertised price.

In September 2026, the agency published price-transparency guidance explaining its position that advertised vehicle prices should reflect the actual price consumers can pay, excluding only charges the government requires consumers to pay directly.

Although this guidance is not a new federal statute, the FTC can still pursue deceptive conduct under existing consumer-protection law.

Dealerships can charge legitimate fees and sell optional products. The issue is whether they advertise prices honestly and clearly explain what buyers must pay.

California Introduces New Car Buying Protections

California’s Combating Auto Retail Scams Act, Senate Bill 766, took effect October 1, 2026. The law establishes requirements covering vehicle advertising, price disclosures, add-on products, certain payment disclosures, and dealership record keeping.

It also provides a cancellation right for qualifying used-vehicle purchases, subject to specific conditions and exceptions.

This does not mean every used-car buyer in California can return a vehicle for any reason. Nor does California’s law automatically apply in every state. Consumer protections and dealership requirements vary by jurisdiction.

Still, the principle is straightforward: An advertised vehicle price should tell buyers what a car costs, not lure them into a dealership with a number that changes when the paperwork appears.

Hidden Dealer Fees Hurt Consumers and Honest Businesses

Deceptive car dealership pricing does more than frustrate consumers. It can also put honest dealerships at a competitive disadvantage.

A dealership advertising a transparent, all-in price may appear more expensive than a competitor that excludes mandatory charges from its headline price. This rewards the lowest advertised number rather than the best overall deal.

The same problem can occur when buyers are encouraged to focus on monthly payments instead of the total purchase price. An additional product might sound inexpensive when presented as a small monthly increase, but the total cost can add up over a multiyear auto loan.

Optional products are not necessarily a bad deal. However, buyers deserve to know their full cost, understand the terms, and determine whether the products are genuinely optional.

How to Protect Yourself From Deceptive Car Pricing

Before buying a vehicle, take these steps to avoid unexpected charges:

  • Request the full price in writing. Ask for an itemized, out-the-door price that includes dealer fees, required add-ons, taxes, and registration costs.
  • Verify advertised discounts. Ask what qualifications apply to rebates and special offers before relying on them.
  • Question mandatory packages. Determine whether accessories, protection plans, and other products are required or optional.
  • Compare total costs. Look beyond monthly payments and compare the complete purchase price and financing terms.
  • Read the paperwork carefully. Check every fee and add-on before signing a purchase or financing agreement.
  • Report suspected deception. If a dealership misrepresents its prices or pressures you into unwanted products, consider filing a complaint with the FTC or your state consumer-protection agency.

These steps can help you identify unexpected charges before they become part of your deal.

Transparent Car Pricing Benefits Everyone

Dealerships have every right to make a profit. Consumers have every right to know what a vehicle costs before committing their time and money.

Regulators must enforce consumer-protection laws fairly, and dealerships should be accountable for the claims they make in their advertising.

When car dealership deceptive pricing becomes a sales strategy, consumers lose the ability to compare offers on a level playing field. Honest dealerships can lose business to competitors advertising prices that do not reflect the actual cost.

The goal should be simple: The price advertised should be the price consumers can reasonably expect to pay, subject to clearly disclosed taxes, government charges, and applicable conditions.

A vehicle’s advertised price should help consumers make an informed decision, not draw them into a dealership with a number that changes when it matters most.


Support Independent Automotive Journalism

You can support my work by buying me a cup of coffee:
www.buymeacoffee.com/laurenfix

Looking for more automotive news? Visit Car Coach Reports.

Listen to The Drive Car Show on YouTube.

About Lauren Fix: Lauren Fix is an automotive expert and journalist covering industry trends, policy changes, and their impact on drivers nationwide. Follow her on X at @LaurenFix for the latest car news and insights.

Scroll to Top